First off Happy Anniversary.
Secondly, I would probably order:
Antipasti: Crostini di Ricotta, only because I've tried versions of everything else of their antipasti. The crostini looks interesting though since I don't think I've had those flavors together before.
Primi: Tagliatelle di Farro and/or Garganelli. Both look interesting and the flavor combinations would be relatively new.
Secondi: Orratta. I've never had that fish before. I've tried the other secondi before.
Dolci: Bruschetta di Prugne: I'm not a big dessert person, so I'd rather have something fruit it in, and this looks interesting.
"Boldness has genius, power, and magic in it."
Johann Wolfgang Von Goethe