Wisconsin - Beer Guide - PubCrawler - Search Results
Try something new! Any amber (pale ales) or golden ale will be tastier than the light beers you're used to. Your area is chock-full of breweries and beer pubs (see above link). Also, don't be afraid of dark beers. Guinness is a stout, but dark ales and porters have a lighter, crisper (usually hoppier) body. THey tend to have coffee, chocolate or caramel flavor, but without as much malt as stouts.
My geography isn't so good... but I love Great Lakes brewery
. You should be able to find that at a nice beer store? Try their Elliot Ness Amber for a nicely balanced, slightly sweet lager.