Bitterness in polenta

The friendliest place on the web for anyone that enjoys cooking.
If you have answers, please help by responding to the unanswered posts.

Hyperion

Senior Cook
Joined
Apr 5, 2011
Messages
340
I have only made polenta once. however in China there's a thinner version of polenta, very similar except thin and doesn't contain any flavoring.

So my gripe about either italian polenta or chinese polenta is with the bitterness in cornmeal. it sits there and bothers me, no matter what I add to it, sugar or chicken stock.

Unfortunately I haven't seen polenta on local restaurant menus so I don't know how it supposed to taste like. How does everyone here prepare polenta, do you also sense the bitterness in it?

Or is the bitterness simply some kind of acquired taste that I have to acquire?
 
How exactly are you making your polenta? I have never had even a hint of bitterness. Polenta is one of the blandest foods around like white rice with nothing on it.
 
Olive oil can be bitter. That could be it. My only other thought is your cornmeal is too old.
 
I'd guess old cornmeal but garlic can also get an off-taste if it gets burned.
 
It's never been bitter to me either. I'd suggest making it as simple as possible, unlike the Alton recipe that has onion, garlic and cheese, and see if it's still bitter to you. Here's the super easy recipe I use.....

1 cup Polenta, 3 1/4 cup luke warm water, 1 tsp salt, 1 tbs butter.
Preheat oven to 350 degrees. Mix ingredients in a buttered 8 in square pan. Bake uncovered for 50 min, then stir with a fork and bake 10 min. more.
Taste it to see if it's bitter to you, and serve with butter and Parmesan, or with your favorite sauce on top.
 
Last edited:
thanks everyone. some of you mentioned the cornmeal being old. well, mine is several months old. should I get replacement?
 
thanks everyone. some of you mentioned the cornmeal being old. well, mine is several months old. should I get replacement?

I'd make small portion of simple grits (no oil) first.

I have a feeling your olive oil may have gone rancid.
 
"something" gone too long would be my guess as well - presuming you've been careful about not burning the garlic & black pepper.... and "old garlic" can also get bitter - if it had any green or sprouting, that's a tip off. we're pretty much at the end of last year crop/storage/distribution - could be the culprit.

you can taste the oil proper - cornmeal does go rancid as it has the plant oil in it - and although you may have it only a short time, there is the "how long has it been on the market shelf or sitting elsewhere in the distribution chain." I keep my corn meal (and other whole grains/flours) in the freezer - not sure how one can tell, other than perhaps smell - or the 'taste test' of a small batch with nothing else...
 
hmm never thought that cornmeal can turn rancid. I'll buy new ones and try again:)

I want to make rabbit stew w/ polenta
 
I keep my cornmeal, masa, and corn flour in the freezer. Not because I ever thought they'd turn rancid, but to keep the bugs out of them.
 

Latest posts

Back
Top Bottom