How to make Rice-a-Roni less mushy

The friendliest place on the web for anyone that enjoys cooking.
If you have answers, please help by responding to the unanswered posts.
Joined
Jun 6, 2013
Messages
95
Location
Southern Illinois
I try to make Rice-a-Roni and if I remember right, after I fry it in butter, I am supposed to add 2 and half cups of water, and bring to a boil, then down to a simmer.


But when it is done, it does not look like the picture, each rice and vermicelli is expanded and forms sort of a mushy content.

What am I doing wrong? Would adding less water make it more like it is supposed to, or would having less heat? What about turning off the burners and restarting them periodically to keep the water still hot but not overheat it, as normally I have the burner as low as it could go without going out.
 
I think you're using too much water and probably cooking it too long. I found a recipe on the Rice-a-Roni site for Seasoned Chicken & Rice that calls for 2 cups of water and cooking for 15-20 minutes. The heat should be around medium so the water stays at a nice simmer. Not a rolling boil, but the water should bubble a bit. hth.
 
I love Rice-A-Roni. All flavors. I pretty much follow the directions on the package, but I add a sprinkling of addtl Minute Rice, so I guess in essence, I'm using less water. I add the HOT water after I brown the rice, and as soon as it starts to bubble and boil, I cover it and turn it down to simmer, stirring occasionally. I think it specifies that the water should be hot before you add it, not just room temp. Also, if the sauce seems watery when it's done, let it sit and it will thicken. We like it so much we want to eat it the minute it's done.
 
Using less water will do the trick. The amount of liquid and the cooking time are the two variables. Since your rice was cooked and soft, cooking time is not the issue.
 
Start making your own. I will never go back to boxed after I made it.Super easy and way better.

measurements are approx. I don't measure this.
2 cups rice
1/2 cup angel hair or vermicelli broken up to 1'' roughly
1/2 cup orzo
1/3 stick butter
1 tsp dried parsley
1/2 tsp sage
1/2 tsp each S&P
2 bay leaves

put everything in a skillet and stir/cook untill vermicelli is browned.
put in a shot of lemon juice or white wine and 2 cans of whatever broth you want. Cover and simmer about 20 minutes.

Play around with spices and onion,garlic etc. I change it up all the time.

Did I mention cheaper too.
 
Last edited:
Start making your own. I will never go back to boxed after I made it.Super easy and way better.

measurements are approx. I don't measure this.
2 cups rice
1/2 cup angel hair or vermicelli broken up to 1'' roughly
1/2 cup orzo
1/3 stick butter
1 tsp dried parsley
1/2 tsp sage
1/2 tsp each S&P
2 bay leaves

put everything in a skillet and stir/cook untill vermicelli is browned.
put in a shot of lemon juice or white wine and 2 cans of whatever broth you want. Cover and simmer about 20 minutes.

Play around with spices and onion,garlic etc. I change it up all the time.

Did I mention cheaper too.

What a good idea, 4me! Thanks for the recipe.
 
I copied the recipe to my recipe file and may try it some time. I am really one who likes the simplicity of the box mix, though. But some day I might want it when I don't have it in the house, then I will try your recipe and then may never buy a box again!
 
You could mix up several recipes of the herb mix and just measure out the amount you need for one recipe of rice. Just like the box but homemade.
 
You do need to check the directions every time. Different flavors (and brands) call for different amounts of water.
 
I use the recipe that I think Andy posted for rice pilaf, it's seriously awesome and so simple, I make it almost weekly and my partner gets excited every time. I just use a couple handfuls of orzo, or broken up angel hair pasta. Make sure to brown the butter and orzo well.

http://www.discusscooking.com/forums/f20/rice-pilaf-75118.html

I pleased you guys like it. I'm sure my mom would have been thrilled to hear others like her recipe.
 
I also gave up on boxed Rice a Roni. It might be just me but it just didn't do it for me anymore, although I have nothing against packaged mixes.

Here's what I do...
Half cup of jasmine rice, half cup of orzo, browned in butter and oil. I add sliced shallots, chopped mushrooms to the saute', and then a handful of golden raisins, with two cups of rich chicken broth and one tablespoon of curry powder. Simmer covered for 15 min on low, fluff, and add some slivered almonds to the mix.
 
Last edited:
You do need to check the directions every time. Different flavors (and brands) call for different amounts of water.

This is a very good point !

As far as the basic Rice A Roni I have never used the amount of water they say to put in. I always use 1-3/4 cup and it always comes out perfect. I do not like my rice to be "soupy" or "saucy" so that's why I put in less water.

Elevation and humidity play a part in it also I've learned in the past.
 
When RAR comes out soupy, It usually means, that the simmer was too low and it usually isn't quite done yet, either. I just give it more time.
 
Sometimes pasta is sold twisted into a round cluster called a nest. The angel hair nests I buy are about an ounce each.
 

Attachments

  • Unknown.jpg
    Unknown.jpg
    10.4 KB · Views: 6,985
Thanks for the pic, Andy. I have seen these in the store. I will just measure out the ounces from my box of angel hair. Would each one of those be considered a serving? That's an easy way to portion it out.

I recently read that the glycemic load of Vermicelli is equal to that of whole wheat pasta, so I would imagine that angel hair is even lower. I always use angel hair or vermicelli.
 
Thanks for the pic, Andy. I have seen these in the store. I will just measure out the ounces from my box of angel hair. Would each one of those be considered a serving? That's an easy way to portion it out...

As I said, two ounces of pasta to a cup of rice. I wouldn't call a one ounce portion a serving. I think three ounces is considered a serving of pasta.
 
Thanks for that homemade recipe...

just one.. well two questions more...

What is Orzo?

And I tried this trick with Chinese fried rice with successful results, about cooking it a day in advance and re-heating it the next day. What will happen if I do that with RiceRoni?
 

Latest posts

Back
Top Bottom