Favorite cheese or cheese blends for Mac & Cheese

The friendliest place on the web for anyone that enjoys cooking.
If you have answers, please help by responding to the unanswered posts.

larry_stewart

Master Chef
Joined
Dec 25, 2006
Messages
6,162
Location
Long Island, New York
I know everyone will have a different answer to this question ( which is why I ask it), but when making your favorite Mac and Cheese, what cheese or cheese blends do you use that , in your opinion, tastes the best.

I've always used cheddar.

Occasionally, Ill throw a few slices of american in there , more for consistency than for taste ( as the cheddar over powers it).

Every now and then I'll use my " I have to clean out the cheese drawer" blend, and basically throw everything in there before it spoils.

Just curious, looking forward to the responses.

larry
 
...Every now and then I'll use my " I have to clean out the cheese drawer" blend, and basically throw everything in there before it spoils...
^That^ is my usual blend! If I'm buying cheese from scratch with mac and cheese in mind, I sometimes get smoked Gouda to use for about half the cheese amount, then add cheap, house brand cheddar since it's usually very lightly flavored.
 
Whatever odds and ends in the freezer for us too, unless we come across a recipe we especially want to try. We've had some sublime M&Cs from the freezer never to be duplicated again, as well as ranging down to okay but nothing special.
 
I'm also in the camp of 'using what's in the cheese drawer'. That usually ends up being cheddar, Monterey jack, smoked gouda, and maybe some muenster.

Like CG, I especially love smoked gouda in my mac and cheese. :yum: I usually buy 2 rounds of it when I'm at TJ's, and purposefully make mac and cheese when there's a decent amount of the gouda left. Delicious. I also like to sprinkle some toasted bread crumbs on top and put it under the broiler for a minute.
 

Attachments

  • mac and cheese.jpg
    mac and cheese.jpg
    50.2 KB · Views: 251
I use sharp cheddar cheese, I also use a little spicy mustard and a big pinch of cayenne. If the cheese is a little wimpy I mince an onion and saute it when I make the roux for the cream sauce, it gives the flavor a little boost.
 
I like Martha Stewart's recipe for Mac and Cheese,
Perfect Macaroni and Cheese Recipe | Martha Stewart
she uses Gruyere, Sharp cheddar and pecorino Romano cheeses
MAN!
DH hated it, "It's too creamy..." (please add whinny little boys voice here :LOL: )
I was in heaven and ate the entire casserole, well, over a period of time of course :blush:

I recently purchased frozen Mac & Cheese with Hatch Chiles at Trader Joe's and I'm very excited to try it.
Hatch Chile Mac & Cheese | Trader Joe's
 
Last edited:
I know everyone will have a different answer to this question ( which is why I ask it), but when making your favorite Mac and Cheese, what cheese or cheese blends do you use that , in your opinion, tastes the best.

I've always used cheddar.

Occasionally, Ill throw a few slices of american in there , more for consistency than for taste ( as the cheddar over powers it).

Every now and then I'll use my " I have to clean out the cheese drawer" blend, and basically throw everything in there before it spoils.

Just curious, looking forward to the responses.

larry

I made it for the first time ever a couple of weeks ago. I was trying to come up with a side dish for Sunday dinner with my father-in-law. I happened to have sharp cheddar and a wedge of parmesan, so that's what I used - about 2 parts cheddar to one part parm. I also had a half a tub of whipped Philly left over from some appetizers my wife made for her golf league, so I threw that in for good measure. I was quite pleased with the results. :yum:
 
I am not a fan of American Cheese, and that includes Velveta. I buy the ends of cheeses that my store puts out. It can have any kind of cheese that they sell at the deli counter. From smoked cheeses to sharp ones. Sort of like your cheese drawer. If I get lucky, there will be as much a 1/4 pound of sliced cheese from an over cut. Perfect for a sandwich. Or an end that hasn't been sliced at all. My favorite of all the cheeses in these packets are the imported Swiss Cheese ones. Ideal for mac and cheese. :angel:
 
I often put cream cheese in mac and cheese to get that creamy texture (and so no one will see me buying Velveeta). A typical blend would be sharp cheddar, a little comte or gruyere and a handfull of parm along with cream cheese. I also add a little mustard, cayenne and black pepper in the sauce. That said, I never met a mac and cheese I didn't like - even the stuff in the blue box.
 
Making Mac and Cheese in Italy was a challenge first time round. Now I reckon my version is fine:

for the cheese sauce:

béchamel
1 part gorgonzola
1 part mascarpone
1 part Swiss gruyère
1 part parmesan or grana padano

For the topping:

Toasted breadcrumbs
sprinkling of fresh or dried thyme
Good dusting of parmesan to get a good crust

that's it

di reston


Enough is never as good as a feast Oscar Wilde


'People of ze wurl, relax!' - famously spoken by the parrot in Tom Robbins' 'Fierce Invalids Home from Hot Climates'
 
I'm a traditionalist, sticking to good cheddar (Coastal brand is great) and lots of it. But I also like to grate a little Costco Parmesan on top for the final brown.
 
If I could get hold of a decent cheddar here, I'd be a traditionalist too! But they don't do anything even resembling Cheddar here, so the combination of cheeses I use works well, our friends all like it, but.....oooh for the real thing!

di reston


Enough is never as good as a feast Oscar Wilde
 
I just looked up Calosso, Piemonte, though the "Piedmonte" was a dead give-away. How about we swap for a year? I'll throw in all the Cheddar you can eat.
 
Where we live is a Unesco Heritage Site of Special Interest, well known both for cuisine and wines, and wild mushrooms and truffles including white truffles which are greatly sought. I have a really good recipe for white truffle risotto, a dish much in demand round here in the autumn. I've tried white truffles with Mac 'n Cheese, and it works very well provided you don't overdo the cheese

di reston

Enough is never as good as a feast Oscar Wilde
 
Back
Top Bottom