Heeeeeelp! Pina Colada Cake Mix Cookies

The friendliest place on the web for anyone that enjoys cooking.
If you have answers, please help by responding to the unanswered posts.

JoeV

Washing Up
Joined
Mar 30, 2008
Messages
1,037
Location
Mentor, OH
I have an Extra Moist Butter Deluxe (store brand) cake mix, coconut, crushed pineapple and a bottle of Bacardi rum (the real stuff, not the extract). Can I make Pina Colado cake cookies with this stuff, or do I need something else. I Googled "Pina Colado Cake Cookies," and it returned no matches, just scratch recipes.

JoeV
 
Hey larry I googled pina colada cake MIX cookies and came up with a few!!! I didnt read through them all, but maybe theres something there you can use! HTH
 
Hey larry I googled pina colada cake MIX cookies and came up with a few!!! I didnt read through them all, but maybe theres something there you can use! HTH

:ermm: Who's Larry? I feel like you're 'steppin' out" on me.

JOEV

BTW, cute new avatar. I can say that cuz I'm a Grandpa.
 
Holy Smokes!!:ohmy:Why did I do that? Ummm ok well must be cause Im old OR because I am INSANE!!! lol:LOL:
SORRY Joe!! It IS halloween after all....must be some witches playing with my keyboard!!!:ermm:
Boy do I feel dumb:neutral:
 
img_715460_0_85aabb3015459a6945209d5cbb34437f.gif
img_715460_0_85aabb3015459a6945209d5cbb34437f.gif
img_715460_0_85aabb3015459a6945209d5cbb34437f.gif
img_715460_3_e107c3207aec0d8c9adc2572c399152f.gif
img_715460_3_e107c3207aec0d8c9adc2572c399152f.gif
img_715460_3_e107c3207aec0d8c9adc2572c399152f.gif
 
I think I would save the butter cake mix and use pineapple cake mix instead. Add a little (very drained) pineapple, some flaked coconut and rum, along with the oil and eggs. I use my potato ricer to drain pineapple if I need it very dry for a recipe.

Let us know how your cookies turn out.
 
I think I would save the butter cake mix and use pineapple cake mix instead. Add a little (very drained) pineapple, some flaked coconut and rum, along with the oil and eggs. I use my potato ricer to drain pineapple if I need it very dry for a recipe.

Let us know how your cookies turn out.

the recipe i found says to do just that katie. use the pineapple cake mix. i do think you need to be careful and only add wet stuff in tiny bits. :chef:
 
I will admit i haven't read the whole thread, but I made pina colada cookies this way and they turned out fine.

1 yellow cake mix
1/4 cup oil
1/4 cup juice from crushed pineapple
1/2 cup really drained crushed pineapple
1/2 cup flaked coconut
1 tsp rum extract (they were for a youth bake sale so couldn't use the real stuff).

Anyways they were a complete hit. Don't know if this helps or not.
 
Back
Top Bottom