Butter in chicken soup? Sorry, just not my cup of tea.
Oh, yeah, and I really did not read the whole thread, because it is obvious that it is I who makes the best Chicken Soup. There is no need to enter my recipe as the original questioner is long gone by now and ain't coming back. And all of you have your own, proven ways of making soup anyways, so no matter what I say, you not going to do it.