Cookie Sheets and Pizza Pans - Favorite Brands?

The friendliest place on the web for anyone that enjoys cooking.
If you have answers, please help by responding to the unanswered posts.

lovetocook07

Assistant Cook
Joined
Apr 26, 2007
Messages
24
Location
Indiana
Not sure if I am in the right place but I am in need of new cookie sheets and pizza pans. What brands do you use and have good luck with?
 
Andy M. said:
I like plain aluminum half sheet pans and cookie sheets.

Right now I have AirBake cookie sheets and they are nice but sometimes a pain to clean since they cant be immersed in water. My pizza pans, I would be embarrassed to let anyone see! :rolleyes:
 
We have 2 huge commercial pizza pans we bought at a restaurant supply place about 25 years ago. Love 'em and they have been USED. If they could talk.

I also have a pizza screen, also from a restaurant supply store.

Another way we cook pizza is on a "stone," which is a giant (about 14 inches in diameter) clay flowerpot underplate that I turn upside down, dust with cornmeal and use. Got it at the garden store.

Have a deep-dish pizza pan, too.

We make a variety of pizzas here. Can you tell?
 
Katie E said:
We have 2 huge commercial pizza pans we bought at a restaurant supply place about 25 years ago. Love 'em and they have been USED. If they could talk.

I also have a pizza screen, also from a restaurant supply store.

Another way we cook pizza is on a "stone," which is a giant (about 14 inches in diameter) clay flowerpot underplate that I turn upside down, dust with cornmeal and use. Got it at the garden store.

Have a deep-dish pizza pan, too.

We make a variety of pizzas here. Can you tell?

Great ideas, thank you! We are in the beginning stages of making our own pizzas and they taste so much better and fresher! Do you have pizza recipes posted here?
 
For the last couple years I have been using baking sheets that I got at Sam's - a three pack for about $10.

They are heavy duty/restaurant quality and work for cookies, roasting veggies, baking chicken and chops etc. I love 'em!
 
Last edited:
PytnPlace said:
For the last couple years I have been using baking sheets that I got at Sam's - a three pack for about $10.

They are heavy duty/restaurant quality and work for cooking, roasting veggies, baking chicken and chops etc. I love 'em!

Wow that was a great deal! I never thought about checking to see what our local Sam's has in stock.
 
lovetocook07 said:
Great ideas, thank you! We are in the beginning stages of making our own pizzas and they taste so much better and fresher! Do you have pizza recipes posted here?

I don't think I have, lovetocook07. I'll have to check, but there you can use your imagination and your taste buds to guide you to a wonderful pizza. Just think of what you like best in pizza and go from there.
 
If you can find a Pampered Chef rep in your area, I strongly recommend their products. I use large bar pans for cookie sheets, baking chicken and a trillion other things. Clean up is a breeze once you get them seasoned and they are very forgiving when you leave things in the oven just a bit too long. They are nothing short of amazing in my view.

Oh...and I have no affiliation with Pampered Chef. Just a very satisfied customer.

Linda
 
I have two air insulated, non-stick (yeah, right!) jelly roll/cookie sheets of unknown origin (I am guessing Martha-Mart or Wally World), so I can alternate, one baking in the oven while I load up the other with my mini-ice cream scoop. Cookies only take 8 to 12 minuters, so ya gotta be a fast cookie sheet loader!

Pizza I put directly on a pizza stone, no pan required. I do, however have two pizza pans around somewhere that someone left behind when they moved out of somewhere I was moving in. One is a coated steel pan and the other is aluminium with a whole bunch of holes in it. If I needed them right now, I couldn't possibly tell you where they got to. I would have to conduct a thorough search of the entire house.
 
Last edited:
I have an assortment of cookie sheets some of which I inherited from my Mother. I always use parchment/pan liner when I bake cookies. We have a GFS Marketplace store near our home where I can purchase pan liners for a reasonable cost. These are full sheet pan size so I have to cut to size which is not a big issue. These make for easy non stick baking and fast clean up.

I have some pizza pans that we purchased at Bed, Bath & Beyond. They are Teflon coated and have multiple holes in the bottom for better crust baking. I usually just use a wooden peel and place the pizza directly on our well seasoned baking stone.

I consider the dough/crust and sauce the most important ingredients in pizza making. That is why I make my own pizza dough and use sauce we make from our home grown tomatoes.

Our son told me that he thinks we have the pizza thing down pat.
 
Last edited:
For the last couple years I have been using baking sheets that I got at Sam's - a three pack for about $10.

They are heavy duty/restaurant quality and work for cookies, roasting veggies, baking chicken and chops etc. I love 'em!

I use these pans for alot of things too. I even make pizza in them! When we have pzza for a crowd, I can make several this size and have lots of pizza for everyone. If I'm just making for my family, I use the Pampered Chef baking stone bar pan or the oblong sheet. The round stones are used by my kids for frozen pizzas.
 
I have the Sams baking sheets too. They are really heavy duty and one of the best bargains I ever got. We have a pizza stone and a pizza pan that I would like to retire. I think that the stone is much better for crisp crust.
 
We bought the Presto Pizza Oven in December. I would not go back to the oven/pan for anything in the world. They now cost about $40 at WW. You can also use them for frozen french fries....crispy. There are many other things that you can put on it as long as it is not too tall. If you wanted a dozen cookies, you could make them on it. You still need a pizza pan to transfer the pizza onto for cutting and serving (not a big deal....sometimes we use an everyday glass serving platter....you can cut the pizza on the platter too)

As for cookie sheets and/or pizza pans, it is the color of the pan that will make the difference in the baking process. A non-stick coated sheet/pan is going to have a variable in the heat distribution. Check your favorite recipes before you purchase.
 
Sam's Air Bake Aluminium - Not Good for Crispy

I have Industrial Aluminum Air Bake sheet pans. This are identical or nearly identical to the sheet pans sold at Sam's. My old pans were cheap non-stick ones. While the new sheet pans are great for many things, I find that is much more difficult to get food crispy.

I would like to get a pair of sheet pans that are thinner and more heat conductive for cooking crispy foods. I thought S/S would be great, but I can only find them at kitchen fantasy (expensive.) What would you recommend for this purpose (not non-stick please?)
 
lentesubigo, I really can't answer your question. We still have a pair of restaurant-quality aluminum pizza pans (not airbake) that we've had for almost 25 years. They have performed beautifully and we have no desire to replace them.

We also have a pizza "screen" purchased at a restaurant supply house we use occasionally, as well as some clay tiles we bought at a home center (Lowe's, The Home Depot, etc.) that we use for pizza and rustic breads.

Be patient. More answers will assuredly come.
 
My double walled cookie sheets, which I would actually call jelly roll pans, are Ekco. I use a pizza stone, so I don't need a pizza pan.

AS far as Pampered Chef is concerned, their products are good quality, but their prices are somewhat unreasonable. I was looking for one of those apple wedge cutters/corers in all stainless steel, no plastic, to repalce the one that fell apart on me after 10 or so years. Pampered Chef was selling one for, I think, around 11 bucks American. I found the same one on the gadget wall at Le Gourmet Chef for $3.00 U.S.D.!
 

Latest posts

Back
Top Bottom