Deformed pan bottoms?

The friendliest place on the web for anyone that enjoys cooking.
If you have answers, please help by responding to the unanswered posts.

Mr_Dove

Senior Cook
Joined
May 12, 2005
Messages
209
Location
Denver
I'm sure that over-heating pans is the cause of pans that are no longer flat on the bottom but what else can be done when you need high temps to sear your meats?

Are high end pans immune to this kind of deformation? I'm considering the purchase of a stainless pan with a thick clad bottom in the hopes that it will be less likely to deform on me.
 
Mr_Dove said:
I'm sure that over-heating pans is the cause of pans that are no longer flat on the bottom but what else can be done when you need high temps to sear your meats?

Are high end pans immune to this kind of deformation? I'm considering the purchase of a stainless pan with a thick clad bottom in the hopes that it will be less likely to deform on me.

Typically speaking, the thinner the metal, the more likely a pan is to deform. I was always told that you never run a hot frying pan under the tap as that will cause it to warp, but that seems to mostly be true of cheaper pans stamped out of thin materials. I will never willingly own a cheap piece of cookware again, after cooking for the the last 3 years with my Emerilware by All Clad ( I know, it's not the best, but it beats anything I ever owned before, and works well for me). I haven't had any problems with warping or with damage to the nonstick coating on any of these pans... :mrgreen:
 
Mr_Dove said:
Are high end pans immune to this kind of deformation? I'm considering the purchase of a stainless pan with a thick clad bottom in the hopes that it will be less likely to deform on me.
Just because it is high end does not mean it will not deform. The key is having a heavy thick pan. Most high end pans fall into this category, but they do not have to. Something like cast iron, which is very inexpensive, is very heavy and very thick and will not warp.

The cheepo lightweight pans will warp very easily though. If you are serious about cooking them get some decent cookware. You will not be sorry.
 
Just to add to what RPCookin and GB said ...

I've got a set of Emerilware Stainless Steel - and I call tell you something about encausulated bottoms ... if you get them too hot the SS discolors, warps, and the aluminum in the base melts all over your stove. The same is true for All-Clad's high end tri-ply stainaless ... read the instructions and warranty. They suggest only using low to medium temperatures.

Having said that - I have no problem getting a good sear on meats at a lower temp that won't destroy my pans.

If you want a pan that you can get blazing hot and will not warp or melt - get a plain ol' cast iron skillet.
 
I ruined a great cookie sheet by running tap water on it while it was still hot, ruined another by cooking a frozen pot pie (gasp) on it. I had put the sheet in the oven while it was heating up and then put the frozen dish on it. :cry:
 
When I bought a smooth-top electric range I looked for the flattest bottom cookware I could find within my budget (I needed new anyway). For my buck a set of Sitram and a couple of Circulon nonstick skillets to supplement them really work well. They're very heavy and very flat and can really take abuse. I really abuse my cookwear (as my husband says, and Mom said when I was young, Claire plays with her toys, she doesn't just look at them) and they've held up admirably. I don't believe nonstick is forever, so don't pay a lot for it and consider it a few years' investment. The Sitram, I suspect, is for life. Some of it has slightly discolored, but I've found that if I take the time to hit it with metal polish (which I seldom do; they're tools, not decorations) I can fix it. As far as cookie sheets and other oven ware, I'm at a loss. As far as I can tell, most will warp. I've never quite figured out whether to just buy cheap and toss them when they aggravate me, or to try more expensive (so far they've only performed marginally better). You have to understand I don't bake cookies on them, which is a few minutes in the oven. I'm much more likely to be experimenting with baking crab cakes, making chicken wings, etc. They get all grease stained and warp like crazy (sometimes you can even hear them pinging with metal fatigue). Are the truly expensive ones any better? (I've done cheap through medium priced and not found a noticeable difference in clean-ability (brother, the vocabulary), but some in the warp factor (i.e., double sided bottoms on the pans don't warp as badly). Any help in the cookie sheet department would be appreciated.
 
I wrote All-Clad about this several months ago and this is their reply.

While we do not recommend the use of high heat that is not to say that the heat cannot be increased carefully. You can use higher heat to sear meats as long as you watch carefully and make sure not to overheat the pan.
 
Claire said:
As far as cookie sheets and other oven ware, I'm at a loss. As far as I can tell, most will warp. I've never quite figured out whether to just buy cheap and toss them when they aggravate me, or to try more expensive (so far they've only performed marginally better). You have to understand I don't bake cookies on them, which is a few minutes in the oven. I'm much more likely to be experimenting with baking crab cakes, making chicken wings, etc. They get all grease stained and warp like crazy (sometimes you can even hear them pinging with metal fatigue). Are the truly expensive ones any better? (I've done cheap through medium priced and not found a noticeable difference in clean-ability (brother, the vocabulary), but some in the warp factor (i.e., double sided bottoms on the pans don't warp as badly). Any help in the cookie sheet department would be appreciated.

Help has arrived!:angel:

Hurry yourself to the restaurant supply store and buy half sheet aluminum bun/sheet pans in the heaviest gauge they carry.

They work in restaurants, they will work in your home. They can possibly warp, but not likely under normal conditions.
img_121937_0_523b31d83120165d42cd5e75806e8f85.jpg
 
you can ruin any pan by thermal shock...over heating it and plunging it into cold water. copper will bulge, steel will warp, iron will crack, stone will explode, glass will implode, you name it. let a pan cool naturally, let it heat slowly, if you must put water in a pan to clean it before it solidifies to rock, put hot water in.

I really don't like encapsulated bottoms. I do own one, my multi cooker pasta pot with basket etc. It boils water fine. But I like the whole pot to radiate the heat into the food from all sides not just the bottom.
 
The most warp resistant cookware I have is my LeCrueset. I also have had no issues with All-Clad, Cuisenart, or KitchenAid cookware.

As said above, any metal will deform if the temps are hot enough or the pan is subjected to a severe themal shock
 
Claire said:
As far as cookie sheets and other oven ware, I'm at a loss. As far as I can tell, most will warp. I've never quite figured out whether to just buy cheap and toss them when they aggravate me, or to try more expensive (so far they've only performed marginally better). You have to understand I don't bake cookies on them, which is a few minutes in the oven. I'm much more likely to be experimenting with baking crab cakes, making chicken wings, etc. They get all grease stained and warp like crazy (sometimes you can even hear them pinging with metal fatigue). Are the truly expensive ones any better? (I've done cheap through medium priced and not found a noticeable difference in clean-ability (brother, the vocabulary), but some in the warp factor (i.e., double sided bottoms on the pans don't warp as badly). Any help in the cookie sheet department would be appreciated.

I'm gradually replacing my metal bakeware with silicon - it's non-stick, doesn't rust, is easy to clean, and you can throw it in the dishwasher. For baking sheets - I just use a good quality non-stick hard-anodized aluminium griddle sheet (I have a Circulon 18" x 10" griddle) - this works just as well (if not better) than a baking sheet, but is far better quality (being 5mm thick aluminium) and so doesn't warp. You can also use a good quality (again 5mm hard-anodized aluminium) large roasting pan...

Paint.
 
Pans warp due to thermal expansion and contraction. Hot spots in isolated areas cause that portion of the pan surface to expand greater than the surounding areas. And if you've never had a physics class to teach you such things, epansion due to heat can produce tons of pressure. Look at any long bridge, or even the highway. You'll notice that they have expansion joints built in. If they were constructed without them, the roads and bridges would crack.

It is also this uneven expansion that causes glass to shatter when it is forced to rapidly change temperature, as when you place a hot glass in cold water, or vice versa. The outside surface cools or heats more closely than does the inner structure of the glass. This causes enormous stress as the expansion or contraction takes place. And remember, glass is an insulator and takes time to transfer heat energy from the outside in.

The same is true of cast-iron. Though it is a contuctor, it is a poor one. It takes a relatively long time to heat upl, and to radiate its heat away as well, which is why its so good at searing and browning meats. But that's also why it cracks when immersed very into icy water. Also, cast iron is fairly brittle, for a metal.

Steel and aluminum are both more resilient than are either glass or cast iron. They tend to bend, or warp when uneven heat is applied. The reason the thicker steel and aluminum resist warping is that they have time to dissipate the heat energy more evenly than their tinner cousins, thereby avoiding uneven thermal expansion. It's like the difference between my sporting 30-06 rifle, and the old M-14 military rifle. They share similar calibers, and similar heat loads from the amunition. But my rifle has a relatively thin barrel. It is accurate for about three shots, and then begins to war slightly, messing up accuracy. The M-14, and its predecessor M-1, and for that matter, most any military rifel, have either thick, heavy barrels that resist warping under high temeratures, or heat dissipating devices attached to the barrels.

And rocks, well two things can cause them to explode; trappe water within the structure can heat and turn to steam. As it is trapped, it can build enough pressure to create a catastrophic failure of the rock struture, i.e., and explosion. The other potential event is that uneven thermal expansion. Like cast-iron, and glass, rocks are poor conductors of heat. Yet, they are subject to the same expansion forces as all other materials. They won't bend, and are brittle. Sounds like a recipe for a at last a crack or at worst a violent shattering, similar to an small explosion.

Well there you have it, physics lesson 231, the results of stress due to thermal expansion on materials, especially where cooking is concerned. :mrgreen:

Seeeeeya; Goodweed of the North
 

Latest posts

Back
Top Bottom