I'm looking at the Dec 2005 CR.
Among the sets tested, the Members Mark rated 5th after:
- KitchenAid Gourmet Essentials Brushed Stainless
- Calphalon Contemporary
- Emerilware Stainless
- Magnalite Classic
The set were rated on:
- Cooking Evenness
- Nonstick durability
- Ease of Cleaning
These 5 all fell into the VG category, as did the next 5 sets.
The MM set received a negative rating for Sturdiness.