My Salsa recipe is bitter, can you help me figure out why?

The friendliest place on the web for anyone that enjoys cooking.
If you have answers, please help by responding to the unanswered posts.

Beer Me

Assistant Cook
Joined
Dec 28, 2005
Messages
4
So I was doing some experimenting this evening on a salsa recipe. It's a fresh recipe with no cooking or boiling (I just chopped it up in my food processor). I just tried it and it sucks! It's got a bitter bite to it. Can you guys help me figure out what's causing it? I think it's one of the peppers I used.

2 whole limes, peeled
4 Clementine oranges
2 green onions
1 large sweet onion
2 cloves garlic
1 bunch cilantro
2 Jalepeno peppers, seeded
1 Anaheim pepper, seeded
1 Poblano pepper, seeded
2 Bell peppers
1/2 teaspoon cumin
4 "On Vine" tomatoes, cored
1 carrot
1 tablespoon salt
 
This is probably pretty obvious, but I did peel the oranges before I put them in.
 
Hi Beer Me, a big welcome to our DC family! :chef:

This might just be me (not a salsa expert by a long shot!) but I tend to think that it looks like there are too many flavours compeating for attention in that recipe. Many of the ingredients (like the carrot, orange and green onions) are "sweet" flavours, but the stronger ones like the chillis, lime and coriander are likely to wash them out.

I'd probably try simplifying the recipe and eliminting some of the ingredients. Use just one or the other of the types of onions and citrus fruit (or use the oranges and add a little lime zest or vice versa). I'd probably drop the cumin too and let the chilli and corriander flavours try to shine through. I wonder if using 3 different hot peppers is really adding much to the flavour (chilli experts please set me straight here, if I'm mistaken), but I can't help but think that the strongest one might just over-power and dominate the taste of the other 2 types.

Not sure if you really need the carrot or bell pepper either, but they may work - play around a little with tiny batches, that way you can try and get the ingredients right without "wasting" a whole batch. Good luck, and welcome to DC :)
 
Anaheims and Poblanos are not hot. But I agree that there are too many types of peppers, especially since it was concocted in a food processor. Raw fresh peppers can taste "grassy" (for lack of a better word) and the combination and amounts of what was added may have caused the bitterness. Some honey, sugar, or more acidity probably would've brought down the bitterness in the salsa and balanced it out.

Another cause could've been the limes and oranges. Although they were peeled, it doesn't sound like they were juiced. The membrane in the fruit could've contributed to the bitterness as well.
 
I'd use the juice of the citrus and leave out the rest of it. The membranes can be bitter. I'd also remove the seeds and the pith from the peppers. Leave in some of the seeds if you want more heat.
 
I agree with Andy. I think it was the citrus pith that made it bitter.

I've never had a bitter pepper but citrus pith and old garlic can definitely be bitter.
 
Hey Beer Me,
Have you ever tried roasting the peppers? Makes for a really good smokey flavor in the salsa.
 
I would suggest a "spoonful of sugar"...(maybe two). Many times that's enough to cut the "bitterness" which is sometimes just the tomatoes. I use 1/2 cup in mine...but I use a gallon of diced tomatoes. It is definately not "sweet"...but it is not bitter either. Good luck!
 
Hey guys, just wanted to give you an update.

I've been working out the kinks in my salsa recipe, and I think I have it down.

I figured out what the original off flavor was - onion. The amount of red onion I used was was too much. I cut it in half and changed to a sweet onion, and voila!

Here's my recipe to date:

2 green bell peppers
1 red bell pepper
1/2 large sweet onion
6 jalepenos
1 habanero
2 carrots or 1 large handful baby carrots
1/4 teaspoon cumin
Leaves from 1 bunch cilantro
2 teaspoon salt
7 Roma or Plum tomatoes
2 teaspoons lime juice
2 teaspoons lemon juice

Of course it tastes better after a day or two in the fridge.

Thanks again to everyone who helped me out!
 
Back
Top Bottom