I've never had Papa John's. We have a new one down the road that they just opened recently and I still have yet to order from them. I should give them a try sometime.
What's funny is the new Papa John's is right on the edge of an intersection that has a pizza place on every corner. Across from Papa John's is Domino's. On the other corner is Cardo's (a local place with the best subs around) and the 4th corner has Stoney's (which used to be good, but we stopped ordering from them years ago when new management took over and ruined the freakin food).
Cardo's and Domino's get most of our business. We're lucky to have a great Domino's team and the food is always hot and fresh. Yes, a good Domino's does exist, LOL. And Cardo's, well, they're a favorite of many on this end of town because their pizza is fantastic and they make awesome subs. Folks will drive from longer distances just to get Cardo's. Luckily for us, it's just minutes down the road.
Sorry, I'm rambling, but what I'm getting at is Papa John's is the only place on those four corners that we haven't tried yet. My son is a huge fan of Cardo's and I personally like Domino's. Their pizza is good, I get rewards (including free food) as my points build up, plus it's affordable.
But maybe next time I'll try Papa John's.