My Creamiest Ice Cream, Ever

The friendliest place on the web for anyone that enjoys cooking.
If you have answers, please help by responding to the unanswered posts.

Chief Longwind Of The North

Certified/Certifiable
Joined
Aug 26, 2004
Messages
12,454
Location
USA,Michigan
I've been down here in the land of trolls with P.A.G, Sprout, and the grandkids since last Tuesday. I've made a couple of requests already, and have a few more to make. Yesterday evening, I made two gellato bases, vanilla, and orange-cream. I'd made various ice cream flavors in the past and so wasn't too worried about making the orange-cream flavor, though It's something that I'd never made, and had no recipe for. Both bases came out silky smooth. I made the vanilla ice cream today and it's the best that I've ever made. Since the orange-cream was made with virtually the same recipe, but with the ingredients to make in orange-cream flavored, I expect it to be as good. The taste of the vanilla that I gave (a tsp. per person) to DW, P.A.G. and myself was extremely satisfying. The vanilla flavor was rich and just plain yummy. But what made it the best that I'd ever made was the texture. It's very creamy and smooth, with no discernible ice crystals at all. It's as good as the best commercial ice creams I've tried.

I'm not telling you this to puff myself up, but to get you to give this recipe a try. Oh, one more thing, this recipe is a hybrid of Italian, and Sicilian gellatto recipes. From what I've read, in most of Europe, and in Italy, egg yolk is used to bind with the water in the base, and control the ice crystal formation. In Sicily, starch is used for the same purpose. In both recipes, the base is cooked, and the yolk, or starch thickens the mixture.

If you want to try the original Sicilian recipe, you can choose from three starches, corn starch, tapioca starch, or arrowroot. The author of the recipe I looked at preferred arrowroot because it creates a somewhat slimy starch when used with dairy products, and she liked that. Of course in the gellato, the sliminess goes away, but the starch gives the finished product a distinct sheen.

Me, I'm not fond of slimy. Gelled, as in aspic, I can handle quite well. But something with the texture of, excuse the reference please, snot, I just can deal with it. So I used cornstarch. Here's the recipe:

1 1/2 cups milk
1 1/2 cups whipping cream
2 tsp. real vanilla extract
1/2 cup cane sugar
2 egg yolks
3 tsp. cornstarch.

Combine the milk, cream, and sugar in a 2 quart saucepan and heat over medium high while stirring until the mixture is steaming, but not boiling. Remove from heat. Mix the cornstarch with a couple tbs. of milk to make a slurry. In a separate bowl, beat the yolks until smooth. Remove a cup-full of the hot milk/cream mixture and slowly whisk into the yolks. Pour both the yolks and slurry back into the pan and place onto the heat. Stir while heating until the mixture just begins boiling and thickens. Remove from the heat and pour through a fine mesh sieve into a container. Put the lid on the container and refrigerate for at least three hours, preferably overnight. When you're ready, pour into your ice cream maker, using the low setting, and process for 35 minutes. Remove to a suitable container and place in the freezer, though this is absolutely at its best straight from the ice cream maker.

For the Orange-Cream flavor, I was going to steep orange zest in the hot milk and cream before I added the thickeners. DW didn't like that idea even though the zest would be strained out. She was afraid the zest would make it bitter. So instead, I used three tsp. of pure orange extract, and 2 tbs. Orange Tang product. I din't use orange juice as the acid would have curdled the milk. This was easier than having to steep orange zest, as I could add the extract and Tang directly into the heating mixture, and so, save some time. The flavor is very good, and the Tang gave just the right color.

I think the vanilla would have been better if I'd had actual vanilla pods, but it's still quite tasty. I think my kids and grandkids will be impressed.

Try the hybrid recipe and see how your next batch of homemade ice cream turns out.

Seeeeeeya; Chief Longwind of the North
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Is 1/4 cup sugar correct? It doesn't seem like enough sweetener for all that milk and cream. The vanilla ice cream recipes I've used have about 3/4 cup sugar for that amount of dairy, and they're not overly sweet.
 
Is 1/4 cup sugar correct? It doesn't seem like enough sweetener for all that milk and cream. The vanilla ice cream recipes I've used have about 3/4 cup sugar for that amount of dairy, and they're not overly sweet.

The recipe should have read 1/2 cup sugar. That's what I used, and the gelato was very sweet.

With the orange flavor batch, it was creamy in the extreme. But since I used the same recipe as for the vanilla gelato, the addition of Tang brand orange breakfast beverage gave me the flavor I was looking for, but also a powdery feel in the final gelato. It was strange to me, and to my daughters that it was so very creamy and smooth, but created a powdery sensation of the tongue at the same time. P.A.G. suggested that maybe the flavor particles in Tang don't dissolve, but are particles in suspension, and that they are responsible for the powdery feel. Sounds plausible to me. So, I need to find something that dissolves, and still won't curdle the milk.

The vanilla was excellent, while the orange-cream gelato needs tweeking.

Seeeeeeya; Chief Longwind of the North
 
I'll have to give your vanilla base a try! I'll likely double it for my old fashioned style ice cream maker.

I like this type of recipe with egg yolks cooked on the stove, it gives the flavor that I remember from childhood. We'd go to the farm in town for cream and churn with 2 machines at a time.
 
Back
Top Bottom