I just saw The Grudge last week and, while indeed 'creepy', I thought it was garbage and would never recommend it. The Ring, on the other hand IS good... as is The Forgotten.
I also saw Friday Night Lights which, I think, is one of the better 'sports movies' ever made. Some seem to like Brian's Song but I think that movie is now so dated and cheesy.
By now most people have probably seen Unforgiven, Clint Eastwood's Western with Danny Glover and Gene Hackman. I really liked that movie.
I saw The Day After Tomorrow in the theater and thought it was worth seeing... as with most big special effects films, the writing was not that great... (unlike The Matrix).
I also thought Vanilla Sky was an interesting movie...
I guess there are a lot out there, huh? And I'm sure there are a ton of good ones I'm missing.