Andy M.
Certified Pretend Chef
We have a Penzey's down the road, so I go there quite a bit. One tip when buying from Penzey's: save the jar and refill with their bulk packages, which come in plastic bags. It's a LOT less expensive than buying a new jar every time.
That's what I do too. You can also buy new bottles with blank labels and make your own. Sadly, the label doesn't take printer ink and smudges. I just duplicated the label graphics on my computer and print my own labels.