I think it would be beautiful. The maple would compliment the golden tones in the tile and add a "warm" quality to the kitchen and the sink would pick up the "whites" in the tile. I think this would be a winner.
The butcher block would also be a less "loud" surface in your kitchen. Tile and granite/marble are very hard surfaces and don't do much to dampen sounds.
The butcher block would also be a less "loud" surface in your kitchen. Tile and granite/marble are very hard surfaces and don't do much to dampen sounds.