Shallots or Onions?

The friendliest place on the web for anyone that enjoys cooking.
If you have answers, please help by responding to the unanswered posts.
See posts with no answers
oldcoot

oldcoot

Senior Cook
Joined
Feb 4, 2003
Messages
487
Location
USA,California
In recipes, and on the various cooking shows, chefs, etc., are forever touting shallots. So I bought a few the other day, expecting great things.

Ha! I tasted a small piece, raw - to me it tasted exactly like a rather pungent, "hot" onion.

This eveing, my wife (an excellent cook) prepared creamed pearl onions. Thinking she had not enough of the pearl onions, she added some chopped shallots. Neither of us could detect any appreciable differnece in flavor.

So what's the big deal about shallots? Is my taster on the fritz, or are they simply over-hyped, like a lot of other stuff these days?
 
No opinions?

Looks like nobody cares much one way or the other about shallots and onions, eh?

Shucks. I was hoping to get a discussion going on onions, etc. You know, which is best - Vidalias or reds or sweet spanish or............Shallots?????
 
I've used shallots before and wasn't too impressed. A bit of a pain to peel and not much difference in flavour. I tend to use spanish onion for pretty much everything but salads where I prefer red ones.
 
Well, I like shallots roasted and they have this incredible sweet flavor (onions do too though) BUT I can roast them whole and in much less time.

If a recipe calls for a small amount of onion I just use a shallot - that way if I don't cook for several days using onion I don't waste the rest.

mmmmmmmmmmm................... I do like Vidalias - but I still don't eat one like an apple - :P IMHO - a sweet onion is a sweet onion is a sweet onion.
 
I love shallots. I use them in anything that doesn't require long cooking and also in salad dressings. Onions I save for anything that is going to simmer for a long time. They taste very different to me; more delicate in flavour. That's it; that's my opinion.
 
Well, Coco, we have a conundrum here: either you have a vivid imagination, enabling you to believe shallots taste very different from just any old rather hot onion, or I have a palate that is shot to pieces and can no longer properly evaluate flavors.

But, hey, as long as you think they're good, and don't mind the hassle of peeling those odd-shaped things, why, have at it. ;)
 
You stick with onions and I'll stick with shallots. My favorite way to have them is sauted with butter and chanterelles, then tossed with linguini and sage. Many a time I have been tempted(and even been caught), to skip the linguini and just eat the chanterelles. :LOL:
 
Shallots (to me at least) taste like a cross between an onion and garlic. The taste difference is very mild in my opinion, but it is there. I do not notice it as much what the shallot is raw, but when sautéed in oil I can notice it. I think that when mixed with regular onion though the flavor difference would be lost.
 
kitchenelf said:
Well, I like shallots roasted and they have this incredible sweet flavor (onions do too though) BUT I can roast them whole and in much less time.

If a recipe calls for a small amount of onion I just use a shallot - that way if I don't cook for several days using onion I don't waste the rest.

mmmmmmmmmmm................... I do like Vidalias - but I still don't eat one like an apple - :P IMHO - a sweet onion is a sweet onion is a sweet onion.
Click to expand...

Ohh, one of the best things I have every tasted was this roasted eshallot and demi-glaze sauce. Ohhhhhhh I have shivers thinking of it. You could throw out the meat and just order more sauce! Although the demi was a pain to make, took like 3 days to make 1 qt from 10 gals of stock.
 
OK....what the heck are chanterelles???? I've never cooked shallots before because I never knew what exactly they were,,,now I do....hmmm...I like my onions but I must try shallots for myself...ive at ethem but just not cooked them....
 
Shallots are just sweeter tancowgirl. But they still make you cry like a baby when you cut up a lot of them!!! LOL

A chanterelle is a type of mushroom. (oops, sorry, I didn't even see ironchef's post) :oops:
 
For Jermosh:

I'm sure there's no substitute for home made demi glace, but we have a couple of alternatives at our store that are very popular:

www.thewhitewhale.com/redibase.htm
www.thewhitewhale.com/gourmet.htm

Not trying to hawk our merchandise, :D but not everyone knows about these bases and they really take your cooking to the next level (kicked up, as Emeril might say?).

I really like shallots and agree that they are milder and have a more sophisticated taste in cooking. They are also very easy to grow. Just buy one at the store and plant the little bulbs. Coot, you may have just gotten a shallot that was over the hill... :roll:
 
If you want to test the difference between onions and shallots, try this:
Make up a batch of coleslaw. Divide it in half and put onion in one half and shallot in the other half, equal portions. Allow the slaw to meld overnight in the refridgerator. Now taste both batches. The difference is wonderful. The shallots give it a mild sweet taste. I'm willing to bet that most people who don't like slaw would like it if it was made with shallots.
 
:D I use shallots in certain salad dressings and other recipes its alot milder.If you dont have shallots you can substitute white onions just use a 1/4 the amount that is called for shallots.
Be sure you get really firm shallots when you buy them if they are soft they are way too old.
 
joesfolks said:
If you want to test the difference between onions and shallots, try this:
Make up a batch of coleslaw. Divide it in half and put onion in one half and shallot in the other half, equal portions. Allow the slaw to meld overnight in the refridgerator. Now taste both batches. The difference is wonderful. The shallots give it a mild sweet taste. I'm willing to bet that most people who don't like slaw would like it if it was made with shallots.
Click to expand...

Don't believe I've ever had coleslaw with either onions or shallots.
 
kfc makes their coleslaw with onions. if you look closely, you can see them but they're chopped ultra-fine.

the best way to tell would be to taste test the difference in uncooked dishes like the coleslaw. make three of the same dishes, one with generic yellow/white onions, one with shallots, and one with sweet vidalia or maui onions. then you can tell which you like better.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

C
10 Things Celebrity Chefs Won't Tell You
Replies
10
Views
2K
Sir_Loin_of_Beef
Sir_Loin_of_Beef
ironchef
For the "Culinary Challenged"
2
Replies
24
Views
4K
secretgarden
S

Latest posts

Back
Top Bottom