Pot For Pasta?

The friendliest place on the web for anyone that enjoys cooking.
If you have answers, please help by responding to the unanswered posts.
See posts with no answers
S

SeanCan'tCook

Cook
Joined
Dec 21, 2008
Messages
86
Location
Tulsa, OK
OK, so I bought a stock pot for pasta. It has a lid with holes in it so you can drain the pasta without having to use a collander.

First, I cook mainly angel hair pasta or thin spaghettis, so the lid was useless as a lot of the pasta would come out of the holes, so I ended up using a fine collander anyway.

Second, it has a non-stick surface. I've used it probably a dozen times since I bought it two years or so, ago, and the non-stick material is flaking off to the pont I can see bare metal. I know this is dangerous, so I quit using it, and am looking for another pasta pot.

I was looking at the store today, and it looks to me like a stainless stock pot for 39.99 is the best option. Is there a better one?

Thanks.
 
When we purchase a pot/pan, we are looking for something that will last a long time. That means a brand known for its quality, which is probably going to be expensive. Expense is relative if you consider something that gives you 20 years to passing it on to the next generation service, compared to a year or two.

Craig
 
There's no reason at all to have a nonstick stockpot. Personally, I don't have use for any nonstick cookware save for a skillet here and there.

If you are going to use your stockpot for what it's meant for -- making stock -- make sure it's a large, tall pot, big enough for lots of bones and veggies, with a good lid.

If all you are going to cook is pasta, any large pot works; the shape doesn't matter that much.

I'd recommend stainless.
 
So what then, is the best pot for cooking pasta?

I'm 53 and single, my cookware won't be heirlooms. I'm looking for the best function at the best price.
 
SeanCan'tCook said:
So what then, is the best pot for cooking pasta?

I'm 53 and single, my cookware won't be heirlooms. I'm looking for the best function at the best price.
Click to expand...

Pick a piece of cookware you think might do the job, with in your price range, google it and see what others think about it. Might take a little time, but it would probably be worth it.

Craig
 
If you are cooking for yourself, you don't need a huge pot for pasta. Buy a good 2 quart stainless or anodized pot, and you can use it for other things as well. If I am reading you right, you are not going to be making home made stock, so you really don't need a huge pot.

I know that some folks will tell you to boil quarts and quarts of water for pasta, but you can make perfect pasta with much less water. For one or two servings, use about a quart of water. Bring the water to a boil, add the pasta, stir once or twice to separate, bring it back to a boil and turn it down a little, so it doesn't boil over.

The two quart pan can be used for cooking vegetables, or for making a small pot of soup or spaghetti sauce.

I have one nonstick pan, that I use only for making eggs.

Probably my most used pan is a 10 inch cast iron from the thrift store. Great for cooking steaks when it is too cool to use the grill. I use it for stir fries, fried chicken, hamburgers, corn bread. I can roast a whole chicken in it in the oven, and make the gravy when the chicken is done.
 
The non stick coating coming off is not dangerous. There is no need to sound money on a new pot. You can continue using you non stick.
 
IMO, you do need a lot of water to cook pasta properly. But the size of the cooking vessel obviously depends on how much pasta you are cooking.

If the only thing, literally, you are cooking is pasta then it pretty much doesn't matter what kind of pot you use. You just need something that can contain a large enough quantity of boiling water.

If you envision using it for other uses, buy a pot that's best for whatever else you are going to use it for.
 
I usually use a stock pot for spaghetti shaped pasta just so all of it fits in without breaking, which means using a lot of water. I have taken to cooking noodles in a sauce pan though, with much less water. The trick is to stir it now and then, which you should be doing anyway. I haven't noticed any difference in the texture of the noodle.
But yes, I'd get a SS stock pot. Mine has a built in collander and a steaming basket. I still lose the skinny pastas through the holes once in a while, but it is what it is.
And while flaked teflon won't hurt you, I'd still ditch the pan just so you don't have to pick out any pieces that decided to come off while using it.
 
Well...you can tell how my mind works. I saw the title and the first thought that flew through my mind was that some one had posted a recipe for a "pot" sauce for pasta.
 
Constance said:
Well...you can tell how my mind works. I saw the title and the first thought that flew through my mind was that some one had posted a recipe for a "pot" sauce for pasta.
Click to expand...

:LOL:

This happened a long time ago in Montreal. The police knocked on the door of an Italian grandmother. They wanted to know who was growing that plant (and pointed at a pot plant) in her front yard. It was her. They told her what it was and that it was illegal to grow it.

She was shocked and somewhat disbelieving. It was the herb that was the secret ingredient in her pasta sauce. She had always grown it, even in the "the old country". Everyone loved her pasta sauce.

I suspect everyone wanted seconds and thirds of that pasta sauce. :ROFLMAO:

Okay, I wasn't there. Maybe it's just an urban legend. I heard it in the '70s, only a few years after it was supposed to have happened.
 
taxlady said:
:LOL:

This happened a long time ago in Montreal. The police knocked on the door of an Italian grandmother. They wanted to know who was growing that plant (and pointed at a pot plant) in her front yard. It was her. They told her what it was and that it was illegal to grow it.

She was shocked and somewhat disbelieving. It was the herb that was the secret ingredient in her pasta sauce. She had always grown it, even in the "the old country". Everyone loved her pasta sauce.

I suspect everyone wanted seconds and thirds of that pasta sauce. :ROFLMAO:

Okay, I wasn't there. Maybe it's just an urban legend. I heard it in the '70s, only a few years after it was supposed to have happened.
Click to expand...

OMG!! :LOL:

About 6 or 7 years ago I was home alone in the middle of a freezing early winter night when I heard all this banging near my back door. So I called the police.

I let them in the front and they walked through to the kitchen where the back door is.

Right there on the kitchen table were about 5 sandwich baggies with dried basil from my garden in them. I had dried it and been lazy about bagging it and giving it to friends. To me it looked just like pot, but I confess to have pretty much forgotten what that looks like.

They didn't say a word, but I was both a bit embarassed and amused by this.

The noise, by the way, was a case of diet coke exploding one can at a time as they froze.:ohmy:
 
I boil pasta in a 5 qt pot with about 4 qts of salted (1 TBS sea salt) rapidly boiling water. When done el dente dip it out with a spider and drop it into the sauce, which should be hot and simmering in another pan. Mix and turn into a serving bowl. Dump out the pasta water when it cools. Lots of recipes for quick pasta sauce that you can prepare while the pasta boils.
 
Thanks for the recommendations.

I was suprised to see people saying the teflon coating flaking off was no big deal. I could swear I've seen a number of stories over the past couple of years about the coatings being carcinogenic, especially after being exposed to high heat, which is what I use to get the water to boil.
 
I believe it is the fumes you are referring to.
Many bird owners keep no non-stick cookware in their home because the fumes from heating can kill a bird. That is why it is recommended you add oil to the pan before turning on the burner, where a SS pan you can do it either way.
 
Yes it is the fumes from heating it empty to extreme high temps. Much much much higher then it could ever get with water in the pot. When boiling water the coating is around the 200 degree mark. It needs to get above 600 to start off gassing.
 
There have been side threads here now and then about the merits and DE-merits of non-stick coatings. If you don't worry about fumes or bits of flaking coating in your food, then you will use non-stick pots. IMHO non-stick is one of those gimics to appeal to folks who don't cook much and who want to avoid fat at any cost. Much of the flavor in food comes from fat or carmelized bits (the fond). Why anyone would think non-stick was necessary in a pasta pot that just boils water is a mystery.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

B
If pasta sticks together after it's cooked, is it overcooked?
2 3
Replies
58
Views
932
Meryl
M
dragnlaw
Clay Pot Cooking question
Replies
16
Views
264
dragnlaw
dragnlaw
priyadogra
Keto Low-Carb Pasta Recipe
Replies
0
Views
383
priyadogra
priyadogra
RileyIGuess
Leeky Risotto
Replies
3
Views
167
Kathleen
Kathleen
Jade Emperor
Fettuccine alla Funghi
Replies
17
Views
270
dragnlaw
dragnlaw

Latest posts

Back
Top Bottom