Squash is tender within but tough near the skin?

The friendliest place on the web for anyone that enjoys cooking.
If you have answers, please help by responding to the unanswered posts.


Senior Cook
May 15, 2020
Prior Lake
I think I made an error this evening, and am unsure what to do next. I was going to make a butternut squash soup and was planning on halving my squash, removing the seeds, and roasting as I always do. But after receiving a call that my friend had gotten into a roll-over car accident (she's totally fine), I panicked and for some reason, before leaving, threw the squash into the oven whole at 350. I left to see her in the ER and came back 2 hours later to a squash that is soft inside, but almost. . .mealy near the skin? Or tough? Gritty? My question is, should I throw this tougher outer layer of butternut squash, (it's only on one side of the squash, maybe it was the side sitting on the roasting pan, I didn't check) or should I perhaps cook it longer? Will blending it into soup nullify this textural stiffness? Does anyone have any idea what happened here?

Latest posts

Top Bottom