Thanksgiving Dinner - Your Menu?

The friendliest place on the web for anyone that enjoys cooking.
If you have answers, please help by responding to the unanswered posts.

PrincessFiona60

Ogress Supreme
Moderator Emeritus
Joined
Jul 14, 2009
Messages
38,955
Location
Wyoming
I didn't know they make such a thing as turkey broth. Will have to look for that around here.

I hadn't ever seen it either. I had to back up and look. Didn't pick it up then because I was on a single minded mission to make sure I had enough weird foods for Shrek to survive the three days I'll be gone.
 

Jessica_Morris

Senior Cook
Joined
Mar 16, 2011
Messages
359
Location
Newnan, Georgia
Thanksgiving is a time where I *love* remembering family through food. Probably not the healthiest thing to do, but I do it anyway.

I'll make a turkey with dressing instead of stuffing. Other sides will be bird nests (with mashed potatoes and cream-peas, dumplings, fresh whole cranberry sauce, perhaps some sweet potatoes with pineapple, relish dish with pickles and olives and stuffed celery, and a decadent "Thanksgiving salad." For dessert, a choice of pies.

VERY carb-heavy, but I simply LOVE Thanksgiving.

Kathleen : Your meal sounds delicious! I ♥ Thanksgiving too because we celebrate with our families and remember all those that are no longer with us. My grandparent's use to invite everyone over to their house for Thanksgiving and Christmas and it was always so much fun. But now both of them are no longer with us, and I'm glad someone decided to pick up the tradition. Thanksgiving and Christmas just wouldn't be the same if we didn't!

I bought my behind the scenes turkey yesterday for 59¢/Lb. So I can start prepping later in the week when it defrosts.

Dinner will be the usual. Good Eats Thanksgiving Turkey, stuffing, rice pilaf, butternut squash, green beans (not casserole) cranberry, gravy. Desserts will include at least a pecan pie and either an apple or lemon meringue pie. SO will make a frosted layer cake for my daughter and grandson as they don't do pie.

Rumor has it SO's son and his new bride will be coming up from FL for Thanksgiving but we've heard those rumors before and been disappointed so we'll just carry on and see what happens.

Andy: I really hope your SO's son will be able to make it with his new bride this year :) And if they don't show, they are definitely missing one heck of a meal this year at Thanksgiving. You've got me craving lemon meringue pie now :yum:

Very quiet Thanksgiving here. Just the two of us.

Glenn has asked for Cornish hens, which I think I'll stuff with wild rice, pineapple and pecans. Homemade cranberry sauce, taters and gravy, probably buttered baby peas, cream cheese/pineapple/lime gelatin salad, some sort of sweet potato side because Glenn really likes them, homemade potato rolls, and some sort of pie. Right now I'm leaning toward an apple-cranberry one I saw a couple of days ago. I may also make a pumpkin one, too, 'cause I sooooo like pumpkin pie for Thanksgiving.

Katie H: I've never cooked a cornish hen before but I've noticed a lot of people are choosing them over turkeys. Turkey for me is just to dry when cooked like instructions say, unless of course you fry your turkey.

How do you cook your home-made potato rolls? I just recently bought a bread making machine and would love to cook some homemade bread. But don't know any recipes
 

Jessica_Morris

Senior Cook
Joined
Mar 16, 2011
Messages
359
Location
Newnan, Georgia
My cousin is hosting this year again, only this time folks sign up on PerfectPotluck.com to bring stuff. I signed up for dressing/stuffing, as I like mine better than the frou-frou I've had, and wine. I just looked, so far we'll have turkey, green bean casserole, sweet potatoes of some sort. Nobody has yet signed up for cranberries, potatoes, or gravy. Might be an interesting dinner.....

Dawgluver: Dressing is one of those meals at Thanksgiving that I can only eat a couple of people's. One of those being mine & one of those being my mothers. If anyone else makes it usually I don't like it :ermm: Although, my grandmother use to make the most delicious dressing at Thanksgiving. But unfortunately she is no longer able to cook nor remember her recipe.

I got my 59 cents per pound turkey today from the local Wegman's store!

Turkey
Roasted Brussels sprouts
Mashed turnip
Cabbage salad
Pickles, olives etc...
Pumpkin pie with whipped cream

Saving all of my carbs for the pumpkin pie! :ermm::ohmy::LOL:

Aunt Bea: Thanksgiving is one of those holiday's that I get so stuffed, but the time dessert comes around I'm too stuffed to even attempt to take a bite of a dessert.

Will be smoking a turkey on Joe to take to a larger family gathering this year. I'm getting off easy for 2013.

.40

There will be 8 of us; 2 sisters and spouses, one nephew with wife and 19 month old son. The dinner will be in the Community House, with other members in attendance as well. I'm doing one turkey, a potato casserole and some canned store bought cranberrry sauce. Don't know the rest of the menu, but I do seem to remember no one has mentioned dessert yet. I am sure that will not be overlooked.

Forty_Caliber: I've never had a smoked turkey, but it sounds DELICIOUS. Our family normally either cooks the turkey in the oven or fries it... What kind of thanksgiving would it be without desserts! Those are always a big hit in our family!
 

Dawgluver

Chef Extraordinaire
Joined
Apr 12, 2011
Messages
25,032
Turkey, mashed potatoes, filling, gravy, cranberry sauce, corn, sweet potatoes, soda, and wine.

Aha! I had to look to see where you were from, Danbuter, had only previously heard the PA relatives call stuffing/dressing filling! And you're from PA!
 
Last edited:

CraigC

Master Chef
Joined
Jan 27, 2011
Messages
6,483
The components of the meal are based on the most importent part of eating that day. The after the post meal nap, T-Day sammich. Piled high with turkey, dressing and jellied cranberry!:yum:

BTW, don't forget the Cold Duck!
 
Last edited:

lyndalou

Head Chef
Joined
Sep 9, 2004
Messages
2,416
Location
USA,Florida
We are invited to friends' home for the holiday. She will cook the turkey, dressing and gravy and the rest of us will bring a side. I have offered to bring a green bean casserole (not from canned stuff but fresh) and/or a potato dish. Haven't heard back, so I'm not sure. I always bring a mince meat pie for her SO. He loves the stuff.I can't wait. This post is making my mouth water.
 

CarolPa

Executive Chef
Joined
Apr 1, 2013
Messages
3,135
Location
Pittsburgh PA
I am hosting Thanksgiving, as usual. I don't invite anyone, they just assume I'm cooking and they come. LOL I never know who's going to show up until the door bell rings. They complain that I don't have enough seating, but there's always more than enough food and they keep coming. I am cooking:

Turkey with bread stuffing and gravy
Mashed Potatoes
Corn
Sweet Potatoes
Cranberry sauce
Pumpkin Pie
Pickles, olives, veggies for munching

They will wander in with a dish of some sort that they choose to bring, a side dish or a dessert. As long as there's wine and beer, they're happy. DH and I have always wanted to go to the casino for Thanksgiving and eat their Thanksgiving buffet, but if I did that, my family would all starve. No one knows the first thing about cooking a turkey. At $20 per person, I am not taking them to the casino with me.
 
Last edited:

CarolPa

Executive Chef
Joined
Apr 1, 2013
Messages
3,135
Location
Pittsburgh PA
Aha! I had to look to see where you were from, Danbuter, had only previously heard the PA relatives call stuffing/dressing filling! And you're from PA!


He must be from the eastern end. I have lived in PA all my life and never heard it called filling, even when we lived in Philly. And he says "soda" whereas we say "pop."
 

Aunt Bea

Master Chef
Joined
Mar 14, 2011
Messages
7,842
Location
near Mount Pilot
I always connect the term filling with Pennsylvania Dutch or Amish cooking.

Some recipes use mashed potato instead of bread or in addition to bread.
 

CarolPa

Executive Chef
Joined
Apr 1, 2013
Messages
3,135
Location
Pittsburgh PA
I always connect the term filling with Pennsylvania Dutch or Amish cooking.

Some recipes use mashed potato instead of bread or in addition to bread.


You are right! I googled "Thanksgiving Filling" and came up with several Amish recipes and they included potatoes.
 

Michellecooks79

Assistant Cook
Joined
Jun 24, 2013
Messages
23
Location
Columbus
I have to find my recipe for sweet potato casserole. My mom is a vegetarian/raw foodist/organic/no processed foods. I have no idea what she will eat.
 

GotGarlic

Chef Extraordinaire
Joined
May 9, 2007
Messages
27,086
Location
Southeastern Virginia
It will likely be just me and DH, but I still make a full Thanksgiving dinner because I LOVE turkey and leftovers. I get the smallest one I can find, usually about 12 pounds, and roast it. I'll make stuffing with raisins, because DH likes it that way, mashed potatoes, gravy, roasted green beans and yeast rolls. Pumpkin pie with freshly whipped cream for dessert.

Because my mom recently had shoulder surgery, I doubt she and my stepfather will want to travel on Thanksgiving, and their house is tiny with only one bedroom, so I'm thinking we will go up on Friday, bring something for a big midday meal and spend the day with them. Whew, run on much, GG? :ROFLMAO:
 

Cheryl J

Chef Extraordinaire
Joined
Jun 4, 2012
Messages
10,080
Location
California
My family loves the traditional, so it's pretty much the same every year - roast turkey, mashed potatoes and gravy, dressing, roasted sweet potatoes, steamed green beans with almonds, and homemade cranberry sauce.

I've been really wanting to try Ina Garten's turkey roulade for a couple of years now, but I must stick with the traditional roast turkey for Thanksgiving. I have to agree that it makes the best turkey sandwiches, and I love those almost as much as the original dinner itself. :yum:

Roasted Turkey Roulade Recipe : Ina Garten : Recipes : Food Network
 

Andy M.

Certified Pretend Chef
Joined
Sep 1, 2004
Messages
49,803
Location
Massachusetts
I made a turkey roulade once. I bought and deboned a whole turkey so there was both light and dark meat. It turned out very nicely and was delicious. It also cooked faster and more evenly so dry white meat was not an issue.

That said, it's just not the same as a Thanksgiving turkey.
 

Cheryl J

Chef Extraordinaire
Joined
Jun 4, 2012
Messages
10,080
Location
California
Good to know, Andy. And I agree, Thanksgiving just wouldn't be the same for my family without the traditional golden roast turkey - with the leftover sandwiches, turkey casseroles, etc. Will try the roulade on a non-holiday meal. :yum:
 

CarolPa

Executive Chef
Joined
Apr 1, 2013
Messages
3,135
Location
Pittsburgh PA
Has anyone here ever made a deep-fried turkey? A couple years ago I bought an electric turkey fryer but I've never used it. It's meant to be used indoors but I would imagine I could put it out on the back porch for safety reasons. The thing that deterred me was the book says the oil has go cool for 5 hours before draining it. I don't have anywhere in my house that I could put that fryer for 5 hours when I have a house full of company. I'm so afraid someone would bump it and get burned with the hot oil. I just had to buy that turkey fryer because I have to buy every new kitchen gaget that comes out.
 

Andy M.

Certified Pretend Chef
Joined
Sep 1, 2004
Messages
49,803
Location
Massachusetts
I've fried a few turkeys in my time. Done right, they are fantastic. You can't stuff it but you can do the stuffing in the oven. That's what I do every year for a roast turkey.

I'd recommend frying outdoors. There's a lot of steam and grease in the air. Cover the fryer and leave it on your deck or yard to cool. It takes a long time for that large quantity of oil to cool down so it can be handled safely. It can stay there overnight if you want.
 
Top Bottom